[quote="hansmoleman"]So after giving it a few thorough reads (wink) here is my feedback.
To start, I thought this comic was great. Not excellent but better than good.
THE GOOD:
- Everyone is spot on about the art, I think it is phenomenal and it really elevates the comic past some of its "flaws" - I hope different series like Snatcher (if we ever get one from Merrick and Fernando again...) will benefit from this.
- I really like the cruelty factor, it is nice to see some more harshness in Fernando's latest comic. It shows the utter disregard for the cute captives beyond just the non-consent sex
- Kaoru's kidnap was HOT. One of the better I've seen from Fernando - the girl herself, the art and gag, the process of it all was great. REALLY what get's me for anything Dofantasy related IS the abduction/kidnapping process, transportation of girls, teasing, storage and of course the sexual debauchery that follows. But it's made so much sweeter with a build up and narrative. That is why I love comics storyboarded like Cheerleaders, Snatcher, South of the Border etc.
- I really like Madison character design and was hoping for new bondage gear but she looked great exposed in her bondage belted-frogtie and it was nice to see her clawing at the door trying to get free
- Setting was fabulous as ever
- Gags...amazing!
THE NOT SO GOOD:
- Too much gangbang for me at the start, I loved the positions they had the girls in but I feel like a couple pages and some panels would suffice. I loved the way they suspended the girls and the gags were still great.
- Not enough story development for me at least but I guess it also makes sense this was more of a "action" issue as the previous was a lot of buildup so can't really complain there
- To me I would have preferred more focus on Irina, Madison/Bree and Kaoru for this issue but it seems like the masses love gangbangs
Overally I'm satisfied with the comic, it was a great and solid effort and kudos to Fernando.
Going forward though I would love to see Snatcher 3 ( I think I have mentioned that over a trillion times) but I hope if it ever happens Fernando/Merrick collaborate to make it a more involved/intimate version of The Snatcher. A 60-pager that dedicates slightly more girl character development in the beginning and in the middle - some more back and forward between the Snatcher and his victims (in the rare occasions they are ungagged hehe), some failed escape attempts, seeing the girls in storage in different bondage positions for the night maybe even 1 ungagged speaking to a gagged girl just as an example. It's these little things to me that make comics a little bit more exciting. It provides a lot of context and frame for the situation beyond what is just intended as well./quote]
Cool, that’s a good critique. Pretty much agree with most of your points there. What elevates this comic is the art. It is great to see Fernando’s art taking on new character. He just draws pretty women in bondage so well, and agree want to see more of this style in SNATCHER and cheerleaders.
I have to admit I think it is good but not one of his best, but I found I simply did not crave to read it over and over again like some of his other releases, and I think it stems from a few points you highlighted. I too loved the kidnap scene and the scenes of Miranda and co. I know the masses love gangbangs, and I fully expect so does Fernando, but agree the start lingered a little too much on this, still a great scene, but needed more development of the plot.
What initially got me about Dofantasy comics was not just the BDSM, but the older comics had plenty of abduction, and bondage involving concealment, storage transport. In fact that probably is what makes a comic stellar for me. Hence I can’t get enough of Merrick’s work as he specialises in this. Plus I love it when the narrative is built up with a pay off. This comic has a lack of that and is mainly all action. But that really is nitpicking with porn. Take Cheerleaders 8. Loved how we got to see the dynamics of the squad before they are ultimately kidnapped, restrained, stored and transported. A great example and it always burns me a little we never got to see more of that scene where the squad is mounted and transported. Fernando did mention a while ago that he had a rough draft of that scene more fleshed out where one of the squad becomes a willing accomplice and helps restrain and abuse the girls in the back of the truck. Man I would have loved to have seen that, but maybe Fernando will flesh it out with a Vol 2 of his art collection.
But it seems Fernando is one of the few who still gets the balance right. Personally we all have our kinks and likes, and Dofantasy does its best to cater to all. But I have noticed that many of my favourite artists are releasing less and less. Hence why I started commissioning some of the said artists a few years ago now, to cater to what I want more. A luxury I suppose, but worth it if it helps support some of the artists, and some of the stuff I gotten from artists really is mainly abduction, concealment, storage and transport, and plenty of gags. I know the artists still love to do it so here’s hoping some of the older artists return to dofantasy and do more of this, but I’m still grateful we get regular comics.
Have to agree love the oriental ladies. Great to see a bit of diversity, but Alice the Korean girl is still my favourite.
Fernando and Merrick with SNATCHER 3 again……………hmmmmm let’s see…….fingers crossed.
